First, consider the following questions:
- Am I the right person?
- Is the timing right - the critical moment?
- Why is it a critical conversation?
With regards to timing, immediately might not be appropriate. However, putting it off for too long and avoiding or delaying the meeting will not improve and may indeed exacerbate the situation under discussion.
After deciding you are the right person and understanding why the conversation is important, try this stepped approach:
- be aware of yourself and how you are communicating
- hear what the other person has to say
- work with the other person to develop positive outcomes, if at all possible.
Having a difficult conversation
Step 1. Consider your:
- body language
- tone of voice
- use of language.
Step 2. Listen and hear:
- understand the broader context
- observe behaviours and emotions
- the need to understand impact and consequences
- keep things as clear and simple as possible.
Your empathy will be key, i.e your ability to keep an open mind and to see things from others' perspective.
Step 3. Problem solving – working in a positive and collaborative way
Conversations which involve different viewpoints reflect a balance of assertiveness and co-operation as shown in the adapted diagram below (Thomas and Kilmann).
Think about conversations and situations you have experienced and identify specific examples in the four categories above. Think about what happened next and what the outcomes were:
- with an accommodating approach?
- with an avoidance approach?
- with a competitive approach?
- with a collaborative approach?
Finally, in preparing for a conversation consider these seven principles:
- be brave and be prepared to get to the real issues
- be yourself and straightforward
- be strongly focused
- be prepared to address really tough issues
- obey your instincts
- manage your emotions
- remember, 'silences can be golden'.
Planning and preparation
- Understand the real issues accurately
- Take advice
- Think about the other person – potential reactions
- Consider the ideal outcome
- Practice what you are going to say
- Allow sufficient time and think about the timing
- Get the environment/location right
- State the issues clearly and honestly
- Provide specific examples and evidence if appropriate
- Be positive and avoid blame
- Focus upon active listening
- Be open-minded and intuitive
- Summarise accurately to demonstrate you have been listening and hearing
- Be self-aware
- Ask open questions
- Ask – don't tell
- Weigh up possibilities and options
- Manage silences
- Allow the time to you both for thinking and responses
- Summarise again and agree the way forward
- Check for shared understanding
- Start with small steps
- Agree a timetable
- Consider if any support is needed
For more information see the AMiE publication 'Managing performance through critical conversations'.
Need further advice?
Your first point of contact is your ATL/AMiE rep in your school or college. Your local ATL/AMiE branch is also available to help with queries, or you can contact AMiE's member advisors on tel: 0345 8118111 or email us. Please have your membership number to hand when telephoning and include it with any correspondence - this will help us to answer your query more quickly.